The technical committee of the BCCI, chaired by the great Sunil Gavaskar is likely to propose a revamp of the Ranji and Duleep Trophy matches for next season. The new proposals would involve scrapping the two division system, and dividing the 27 Ranji Sides in 3 groups of 9 teams each. The top two teams from each group would advance to the next stage, which would consist of the 6 teams being split into 2 groups of 3, which will then play a round robin match up. Two teams from each group would make the knock out semifinal stage.
In this proposed format, each Ranji team would have the chance to play 8 first class matches. Six of the teams will have the chance to play 10 first class matches, Four teams will play 11 and the finalists will play 12.
This would mean that the national side playing 9-10 Test matches in a full year (in 2007 India are likely to play 8-10 Tests, despite it being a World Cup year), would play as much first class cricket as the average Ranji Trophy player. These would of course be 5 day matches, while the Ranji player would play Eight 4 day matches. That in my view is too little cricket.
The idea of creating 3 groups of 9 teams is a good one – it might even be possible to break the country up into three zones instead of the existing 5. However, instead of the next stage comprising of 2 groups of 3 teams, i would propose the following:
You have 3 groups of 9 – and these would play in a league – each side playing 8 matches. I would suggest that the top 3 out of each group should advance to the next round and a new league of 9 teams be formed. But, (borrowing an idea from the World Cup), each of the sides would play 6 matches in the new league, with the results against teams from the original group would be carried over. Therefore, the Ranji Trophy Champions would play 16 matches in all, while the teams which make the elite group will play 14 matches in all.
Coming to the 6 teams in each of the original groups which do not make the knock out – they would play in a Level 2 league of 9 teams (similarly formed by choosing positions 4,5,6 from each group). The Level 3 leagues (positions 7,8,9 from each group) would play a round robin league. Each of these leagues would have winners.
What purpose would this serve? Apart from providing opportunities for teams to play first class cricket more than they have been playing before – it would help determine the seeding for next season. The Elite league would be seeded 1-9, the Level 2 league winners would be seeded 10th, with the other sides being seeded 10-18, while the level 3 league would be seeded 19-27.
The seeding would determine the formation of groups for the next season. So for example, Group A for the next season would consist of seeds 1,4,7, 10, 13, 16, 19, 22 and 25. Group B for the next season would consist of 2, 5, 8, 11, 14, 17, 20, 23 and 26 while Group C for the next season would consist of 3, 6, ….. 27.
What this would ensure is that a minimum of 14 first class matches are played by each side. It would serve the national team well because it would provide opportunities for Test players to play in first class match more than the current schedule does.
The Ranji Trophy Champions should be given the honor of playing the visiting Test team in a tour match. The Irani Trophy as we know it today (Ranji Champions v Rest of India) should be scrapped. As a season opener, it should consist of the Test team playing a Rest of India side (effectively an India A side).
The Duleep Trophy, even if it becomes non-zonal needs to be scrapped, because scratch squads would result only in the matches turning into selection matches. Instead of the Duleep Trophy the Level 2 and Level 3 leagues proposed above would serve as better contests, because they will involve real Teams and not scratch combinations.
The annual ODI tournament would be along similar lines, played over 2-3 weeks at the end of the first class season.
The Indian Cricket Season would then look like this:
Season Opener: Irani Trophy – India (Test team) v Rest of India – early October
Salve Challenger: ODI tournament – following the Irani Trophy
Ranji Trophy: The first league to be completed by December (8 matches per team). The second league (Elite, Level 2 and Level 3 – 6 matches per side + knock out matches for the sides top 4 out of 9 teams in each league) to be played in January, February.
Ranji OD Tournament: Along similar lines – each side getting 14 One Day Matches – Played in March.
The Test Team schedule needs to include only the Irani Trophy – this will serve them well as a tough season opening test.
The problem with India’s domestic cricket has been too little cricket. More Cricket will improve standards of grounds (which will be used more and hence will be maintained more often), umpires (they will have to be professional) and players.
What will be the performance benchmarks for a first class season comprising 14-16 first class matches ? 100 wickets, and 1500 runs?
The English season had too much cricket at one time, and now it possibly has too little. If the first class matches are televised, it will also probably allow BCCI to have a dedicated 24-7 Cricket feed, create a genuine national sporting league and hopefully encourage other sports to follow suit.
The ideas under consideration (going by the the TOI article) don’t go far enough in my opinion. The non-zonal Duleep Trophy is especially pointless, for matches which would be little more than selection trials serve no purpose. What better selection trial can you have other than a team fighting for the highest possible seeding to get a favorable position in next years league?
CricketingView